Sense to Save

Join me on my journey to live a more frugal lifestyle. Here, you'll find common sense and not-so-common sense on ways you can save money.
BlogHer Ad Network
More from BlogHer Advertise here BlogHerPrivacy Policy


Discussions

Keep up with discussions via RSS: Click Here

This Week's Top Commentators

    tiffanie (6) Hadias (4) Alyssa @ Keeping ... (3) FFB (3) Ariel (2) castocreations (2) Emily (2)

Recent Comments


Advertisement

Compare hundreds of loans at a glance with help from The Thrifty Scot

Advertisement

Find exactly the right secured loan for you with the loans specialists at Accepted.co.uk.

Cash, debit or credit?




January 10th, 2008 at 9:02 am

I don’t like cash.

I don’t like to think about how filthy it is–where it’s been and who has handled it.

I don’t like to have it in my purse. I’ve never misplaced money, but to me, it just feels more “losable.”

When I have cash, I spend it and I don’t remember where it goes.

So, I carry just a tiny bit of cash. I have a $20 in my glove box in case I’m out and absolutely need cash, and I regularly get rolls of quarters so I can do my laundry. That’s about it.

Instead of toting twenties, I prefer plastic.

I use my Visa debit card everywhere–Aldi, other groceries, drugstores, whatever. There’s a small rewards program linked to our debit cards, and we’ve earned enough to get a $50 gift card to Outback steakhouse. It should be here soon!

What’s more, I like how my debit card can help me track my spending. I don’t have to write down that I spent $10.26 at a store. My bank already has it logged, and I can link my online bank account to a financial program (such as Microsoft Money or Yodlee) to help me categorize my spending.

I use my credit card for online purchases. I know that I can use my debit card there, but I prefer credit. I can generate a one-time use account number, and it makes me feel much safer.

However, I know that for some people, using a cash-only system works best. You can withdraw a certain amount of money for your weekly expenses, and when it’s gone, it’s gone until your next paycheck. A cash system can work well in those cases.

And, not all stores will accept plastic. I’ve had to leave a few stores empty-handed because of their policy.

What do you use? All one thing? Or maybe a hybrid system?  

Related posts
|2 things: ‘Saving’ money & merchant fees |Credit card rewards can be good (or really bad) |April went well, and hopefully May will, too

RSS feed | Trackback URI Nofollow


12 Comments »

Comment by rocketc
2008-01-10 10:39:47

Hmmm, I prefer plastic as well (pay off balance every month, only buy things you need). I never thought about how dirty money is.

Thanks alot. Now I have another cleanliness phobia.

 
Comment by Bj
2008-01-10 10:49:25

I use strictly plastic for the ease of use, and the cashback bonus money. I pay it off monthly and I try to only buy what I need, but sometimes I find it easy to buy items that I want. Which makes me wonder if I should only use the credit on items such as gas, groceries, and bills. And if I don’t have cash for the item (clothes, dining), I don’t buy it. Although it would make life more difficult I think that I would spend less.

People always say you can control spending by using cash because you are less likely to spend. I am starting to beleive this.

Comment by Kacie
2008-01-10 14:22:11

Excellent point about being able to pay the balance. Sometimes, it is easier to spend more with plastic.

 
 
Comment by Jon
2008-01-10 11:33:12

I do almost exactly the same thing. I never use cash because I always end up spending it, and then I can’t keep track of where its going.

I use a debit card for every purchase. Luckily these days almost everyone accepts a card. The advantage is that when I check my account online I have a list of all the purchases I made that month - that helps me create and maintain my budget.

For bigger purchases I save before hand (most of the time), and pay with a credit card. After I buy I go and immediately pay it off with my debit card.

 
Comment by Bethany
2008-01-10 12:01:52

I’m a heavy debit card user, and have been since I first got one in high school. I almost never had cash in my wallet until recently, when I tried having it around for those cash-only places and instances when the amount was so small I felt silly putting it on my card. I don’t have a credit card, but I’m considering getting a specific one for the frequent flyer miles I can get.

 
Comment by Meredith
2008-01-10 13:41:10

I used to use debit/credit only. But this year DH and I have started taking out a small amount of cash every pay for our extra stuff like eating out, Starbucks etc… For us, it is easier to do cash for this stuff b/c when it is gone it is gone, and I don’t have to stop and think what I have spent so far for the week. We are still new to this though, so not sure if it will last or not! :)

Comment by Kacie
2008-01-10 14:28:42

I’ve tried having like $5-10 in “blow money” to use without worrying about where it goes, but then I have a hard time spending it at all.

 
 
Comment by white rabbit
2008-01-10 14:04:49

Most banknotes have traces of cocaine: fact.

Creit cards are all very well if you pay them off before penalties & interest. Never quite got the hang of that one…

 
Comment by Mrs. Micah
2008-01-10 21:20:20

I use debit. Being able to see the numbers on my computer screen makes using debit very real.

 
2008-01-11 13:29:41

Interesting question. I have always used my debit card. I see a lot of value in having cash, but recently I set up an Excel spreadsheet to keep track of our budget. I’ve been writing down the totals every time I go to the store and it automatically updates and tells me how much of my budget I have left for the month. These hard numbers have been good about controlling my spending. I can see if I keep up with this then it will be just as effective as cash.

I don’t like using my debit card for purchases under $10, so it helps curb my impulse buying on small things. If I have cash, I treat it more like “blow money” (that term really makes me think of drugs!) and spend it wherever even if it’s technically for groceries. I don’t know, we’ll see.

I think each person should try both and use what works better for them. With cash, I am not likely to overspend. With my debit card, I have a record of each purchase and I can’t just “ignore” it like I can with cash. We’ll see in the next few months what works better for us.

 
2008-01-11 16:59:23

I never have cash on me. I use my CC for the cash back and we pay off our bill monthly.

 
2008-05-22 12:41:26

[...] mentioned in the past that Shane and I are total debit card people. We hate using cash, generally. But, on vacation, I think it’s the right way to go. We took [...]

 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

This blog uses the CommentLuv plugin which will try and parse your sites feed and display a link to your last post, please be patient while it tries to find it for you.
Previous Post: Selling on eBay
Next Post: A $37.88 shopping week